Home

Regardless of your mood or dietary restrictions, if you're looking for homemade food in a family setting, Lefty's Tavern is the place to be. Our locally owned and operated restaurant offers a formal dining area, tavern, banquet hall and catering services to suit your needs. We feature an eclectic menu of American food at prices that won't deplete your wallet.

We'll treat you like we treat our employees - just like family. We're proud to be a part of the local community. Visit Lefty's Tavern in Barnegat & serving in Toms River, Manahawkin, Waretown, LBI, Bayville and Ocean County, NJ for your next meal.

Situated in the heart of Barnegat, we’re the local go-to for fresh, made-from-scratch bagels baked daily. Whether you like them toasted, topped with rich cream cheese, or served as one of our signature breakfast sandwiches – like the classic bacon, egg, and cheese – we’ve got the perfect start to your morning.

Since 1984, Andrea Esposito has been serving up culinary delights for Naples’ customers, many of whom return for the delicious food week after week. With several varieties of freshly made pizza, served up 7 days per week, sumptuous Italian homestyle meals and an amazingly friendly atmosphere, it’s easy to understand why it’s such a favorite.

Dedicated to providing the best possible experience for our customers. Whether grabbing a quick slice for lunch, enjoying dinner with friends and family, or catering a special event, we have everything you need to make your visit memorable.